“It is not the
honor that you take with you, but the heritage you leave behind”… Branch
Rickey.
Wesley Branch Rickey was an American baseball player and sports
executive. He was perhaps best known for breaking Major League Baseball's color
barriers by signing African American player & he turned a motivational
speaker in later years of career. Often great quotes have come from great
players or artists as may be because their performance itself becomes our
heritage for the next generations, which gets reflected in words coming from
them, is what I feel. As when I read the news successively about a proposal of
demolishing existing Balgandharva Rang Mandir i.e. BRM (actually theater isn’t
the term I will like to use) it’s the words used in the quote came to my mind.
Will share a bit about BRM, the work started in 1061 & the building get in
to operation in 1968 (year of my birth, a coincidence), considering the speed
with which our govt departments actually works, that was pretty fast I must
say. Spread on nearly 30,000 sft area of land, this 1000 persons capacity
theater cum auditorium soon become pride of Pune & a modern times heritage.
It has also got an art gallery, first of its kind that time in Pune, spread
over 3000sft in addition to theater & spacious parking. What’s more
important is its most strategic location as it right in the centre of city
& on JM road which is probably the link between east & west of the
city. No wonder soon the BRM becomes a land mark not as a theater for dramas
& many cultural programs but became an address by itself for modern Pune.
And what more irony it could have been there that in golden
jubilee year (50th) of this iconic structure, discussions are going
about demolishing it! Since the news got out there has been as usual debates,
commotions going on in social as well news media from both sides. No wonder every political party now days wants to be part of
anything which is trending socially, so immediately all other parties other
than ruling parties jumped in to oppose the decision of demolishing this heritage
structure & pride of Pune. Well, its these same political parties when was
in ruling I don’t remember giving a damn about maintaining this pride of Pune
neither ever bothered that it’s been put on use for which Balgandharva Rang
Mandir has been built. Because for years now there has been war between the artists’s
associations versus the political part for allowing this building to use for
respective use. As the building belongs to PMC means as political
bosses (as per the logic which goes in PMC, that any public building is owned
by them) wish they will use it. No wonder with its central location &
vicinity to PMC itself, most of the political events are carried out majorly in
BRM. This makes impact in very bad way on cultural programs as most of these
political problems are fixed at eleventh hour & as per the convenience of
political bosses, it affects schedule of pre-booked cultural events like dramas
or some art show. At the same time the kind of visitors come here for political
events, well we all know the way our dear ‘karyakartas” of all parties uses any
public property; making life difficult for the actual users who come here for
art & culture! And then when you
say owe something, it’s not done by having your name on property card of that
structure, it’s by the way how you maintain or look after that structure &
on this front why Balgandharva Rang Mandir but every public structure no govt
dept deserves to own, such pathetic way they are maintained. Even about BRM,
right from the artists to audience, everybody has slammed PMC for worst maintenance
of sitting chairs, back stage arrangements, sound as well AC systems & lastly
the toilets; well do I required to say more about the public hygiene aspect of
our city? And it’s not only the Balgandharva
Rang Mandir, look at any so called monuments or heritage buildings in the city
or even the places like Paravti or Railway station & many such, what we see
is disgusting state of maintenance which actually displays the true culture of
our city i.e. our dirty & negligent attitude towards our so called
heritage, though many die hard Punekars won’t like it but it’s a bitter truth! Name one single
place (not Malls or IT buildings) where we can take our outsider guests &
show them cultural or heritage places of the city! And for a city which boosts
itself as cultural capitol of the State, this surely isn’t thing of pride!
So, on this
background I question to all the Punekar’s do we deserve to have heritage
structures like Balgandharva Rang Mandir in first place? And if yes then what
we are doing to maintain them in proper condition & shape as well put to
right use for which we have built them? And when we have failed to perform
our duty towards this monument to allow it to exist with pride then what moral
right we have, to say not to demolish it? Now, the aspect of
necessity of demolishing BRM comes in picture as it’s not the action but
intention behind the action is what matters me most. No specific reason has
been given to demolish the Balgandharva Rang Mandir by the rulers rather this
is what bug me most, as if your intentions are clear & clean then why are
you afraid of justifying the action by putting it in open? As if Punekar
considers BRM as their heritage then let them know the need to demolish is more
important for the city & build something better at the same place which
will fulfill the increased cultural as well artistic needs of this so called Cultural
Capitol City! But then inside currents says different story as the very
convenient location for the Metro interchange nearby this place can be used as
parking need for the Metro travelers & to cater that under the name of
rebuilding of BRM, this existing structure is planned to be demolished is what
inside whispers says! If this is the truth then the action of demolishing needs
to be condemned as city already lacks on cultural outlets is a fact & BRM
is one of the finest (like a fraze in Marathi, “wasarat langdi guy shahani”), I
mean whatever we have at hand in comparison to that, & demolishing it &
building something which will be focused around a parking lot & other
commercial activities & in between all that somewhere an auditorium for
performing arts, is definitely not accepted! As we are in 21stcentury
& if only parking is the issue then it can be done below the building,
keeping the building intact or even below the PMC building itself. Joke is when we knew upcoming Metro &
its route since last ten years, yet the new building has been build in PMC premise
recently which could have been build with multi level parking-lot below it for
the proposed Metro interchange at PMC; but then planning was, is & will
never be our forte, is unfortunate fortune of this city! Agreed both above
options wouldn’t be easy but then surely it would have been lot easier &
less costly than demolishing BRM & taking away cultural outlet for the
citizens for at least next five years. As that much time will be required to
build anything new with best possible speed of our govt system & then who
guaranties that interest of the citizens will be taken care in new structure?
As once the existing structure is demolished then we will be entirely at mercy
of the new PPP model where interests of the commercial benefits occurring out
of this development will be more important under the name of feasibility of the
project!
Here I remember one of the cases in Amsterdam, Holland with my
friend who resides there. In his neighborhood there was a beautiful park &
a public building. After some years the civic body realized that to maintain
this building isn’t a viable or feasible thing so they deiced to convert it in
a commercial development. But before that they called every family living in
the visual vicinity of this existing public building & park, showed them
the proposed development in which all care has been taken not to disturb the
view of day to day activities like parking or traffic in the neighborhood.
Opinions in written has been asked by the residents around, their suggestions
incorporated, the purpose & need of demolishing the existing public
building was explained to them & only after consent of majority of the
residents around the said public building was demolished & a new
development was done! I think this
is where a developed country defers from our beloved country, which we
considered as progressing but the said progress is just for few & never for
the masses. Though this doesn’t defines the so called opponents (read political
parties) of the demolishment decision of BRM right, as they are opposing for
their own selfish reasons & surely not for the interest of the city.
At the same time BRM isn’t the first heritage to give way for
our so called development plans of future as I remember when I came to Pune in
mid eighties there was a huge fountain at university road, where stands now a
fly over. That fountain in a way was heritage for the city as lets first
understand how we define something as heritage. By Cambridge Dictionary
a heritage means, “features (read
monuments) belonging to the culture of a particular society, such as traditions, languages, or buildings, that
were created in the past and
still have historical importance”. Well,
this definition is by dictionary; by me, a heritage monument, it can be a
place, a surrounding, a structure which has been part of our society where
people has spent their time as well which has been part of memories of the
masses over sizable time span (mostly for good reasons). A heritage can be manmade or even natural too as not
necessary as it’s not the creator but the people who are beneficiary of these
creations makes it an heritage. Like the university road fountain, there are
many such places in every city around which memories of generations has been
tied of & this is what we need to understand while we think of development.
Rather high time a city level policy should be made (by the way, there is a
heritage cell at PMC) not just to identify the heritages but how much weightage
we give them while we restructure the city for future needs. Because a heritage
for one generation may be obstacle or inadequate for next generation, in such
case does it really remains a heritage or not is the question. Agreed BRM is
here for fifty years & have been witness to many important moments in these
five decades but may be its purpose is done can also be other side of the coin.
Only thing is today its BRM tomorrow it will be PMC building itself as looking
at the spread & volume of workload, sure the existing building of PMC will
be required to rebuild to take care the expectation from the same & so does
many public buildings. As all these buildings which today we are calling as
heritage are built for need of past era & may be they are not suitable for today’s
demands. But demolishing of such structures is justified only if they are
really failing to deliver for what they have been build for & we (read
govt) has taken genuine efforts to maintain them in their best form. Which
definitely is not the case with BRM & that’s why personally I feel we
should rethink demolishing of BRM!
Because with every passing
year something new will come up & old has to give way for the new entrants
is the law of nature. Still every generation will leave behind something for
coming generation & it may not be necessarily some garden or structure but
what philosophy or culture we will be leaving behind for our next generation
will be the real heritage! After demolishing Balgandharva
Rang Mandir building there might come some more better building on its place
but the true purpose or thought process behind the decision of demolishing it,
will be the real heritage we will be leaving for the next generation & that
is what will decide fate of our society & not just city is the fact we
should understand today!
--
Sanjay
Deshpande
Sanjeevani Dev.
Please view my sharing about real estate in Pune at U-Tube link below..
Please view my sharing about real estate in Pune at U-Tube link below..
Please do visit my blogs to know about our philosophy at Sanjeevani ! (Click the links below)
http://jivnachadrushtikon.blogspot.in/
Social Side of Sanjeevani ! (Click link below)
http://www.flickr.com/photos/65629150@N06/sets/72157627904681345/
For any of your complaints about city, log in at link below
www.punecorporation.org
Think Green, Think Life
www.sanjeevanideve.com
Social Side of Sanjeevani ! (Click link below)
http://www.flickr.com/photos/65629150@N06/sets/72157627904681345/
For any of your complaints about city, log in at link below
www.punecorporation.org
Think Green, Think Life
www.sanjeevanideve.com
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please leave ur name, email id along with ur comment. It will help me to reply ur comment as well improve the blog as per ur suggestions if any... :)
Sanjay