----
“Traffic
congestion is caused by vehicles, not by people in themselves.” … Jane
Jacobs
I owe
half of my sharing to Jane as what I wanted to say in hundreds of the words
that she tells in mere ten words! But then that’s why she is the author of a
book “The Death & Life of Great American Cities” which is a bible, Geeta,
& whatever you can call it for Urban Planning & as usual problem is
neither our citizens nor our rulers believe in reading such books or referring
the content these wisdom treasures carries & outcome is, all we do is blame
each other for any civic problem we face! If you are confused about which civic
problem, recently the headline news may make you think, if Chandni Chowk
flyover is completed then all the city’s traffic problems will be solved, such
is the hype. Well, this Chandni Chowk is nothing to do with Delhi’s famous
place with same name but is a crossing over Mumbai-Bengaluru highway on western
(Kothrud) side of Pune city at which new fly over work is going on (for ages,
sarcastic me) & traffic has become chaos for the commuters from that
stretch! Now one may say what’s so big deal in it, like our dear SRK (don’t ask
who is he plz), “bade bade Shaherome, chote chote hadase hote rahete hai” i.e.,
in big city’s small accidents keep happening, here accident is used as analogy
& read it as inconvenience to the citizens!
Well, now
you have been introduced to the subject of the sharing (partially) then you
will say development work are part of the growth & during their
construction some inconvenience is bound to happen as one can’t build a bridge
or a road or Metro line or a flyover overnight with a magic wand & as a
civil engineer by myself, I agree with this logic hundred percent! But then
it's not about just one fly over or inconvenience caused while building it but
it's about our attitude towards the entire process named development in &
around cities, is the matter of sharing. As for last two years that work is
going on in Chandni Chowk which is a major junction or hub for millions of
commuters but it took Hon Chief Minister’s convoy getting stuck in the traffic
jam this work causes every day, to speed up the steps required to reduce the
traffic jam, is the matter of my sharing! And now the present connecting bridge
will be demolished as Noida Towers (its a in phrase at present) is what Hon CM
announced & as usual in Pune this also went into controversy. I will come
to reference of Noida Towers later but let’s look at our attitude towards
public works at large especially when they are directly related to the citizens
day to day life & road or fly over or Metro is at the core of it in a city
like Pune where numbers of vehicles are more than number of people living in
it.
This
bitter fact about the millions of the private vehicles needed to be on the roads
is the first & foremost failure of Pune as a city, as right from BRT (plz
don’t ask the longform), to merging PMC & PCMC public bus service to HCMTR
(again, no long form plz) to, to Riverside Road to Metro routes & now
Chandni Chowk & yes University Chowk Grade Separator, so many options have
been tried (and has failed) & all
these on the hard-earned public tax money staying in legal homes in this city
(about legal homes, later)! And yet this city is getting choked everyday
everywhere in the traffic, it’s a shame for all the so-called educated &
wise citizens of Pune & I mean each of us, not just govt! The very reason
is we are trying to accommodate more vehicles than reducing them as Jane Jacob
says, it’s the vehicles which cause the traffic jams & not the people. I am
sorry Jane, I differ here with your logic about the traffic (for the first time
with you), as your law is right but it’s the few people who are responsible to
force other many people use the vehicles which in turn causes the traffic jams,
so it’s not the vehicles but the people only, are responsible for traffic jams,
is the fact for Pune city at least! And then it’s the “Chalta hai” attitude
of our govt & Janata which again is the result that the development works
keeps going for years & till they get complete the basic purpose is
defeated, Satara Highway is classic example of it as the time one stretch of
the road gets functional the next stretch of the road needs repairing, making
the journey a nightmare! At the same time while such works are going on the
very Govt which hangs private industries (read as builders) for any mishap at
their respective workplaces turns a blind eye, ear, nose towards their own
safety norms. If you are so naïve not to believe me, then walk on Karve Road or
Baner Road where Metro work is going on (if you come back safely) & share
your view about road safety to me. No wonder the city witnesses nearly 300 plus
deaths on the road (in one month) & nearly 100 nos. of them are pedestrians
who have no choice but walk on the roads without any safety gear for them! And on top of it ignorant attitude of the
two & four-wheeler drivers towards the pedestrians or towards entire
traffic rules, I deliberately excluded 3-wheeler drivers i.e., our aur rikshaws,
as they think they are above any traffic rules so no use in considering them!
Need of
the time was, is & will be a strong, safe, dedicated, disciplined public
transport in place & unfortunately we have PMPML but we don’t have someone
who will make few people in the system know the importance of this weapon
against traffic jams, that’s the object of my sharing! As having PMPML in place in its
present status in the city as traffic solution is like having a watch-dog of
good breed in the home but it’s tied all the time, not given proper food &
not allowed to bark yet when the theft happens then only the dog is blamed for
negligence in the duty of guarding the home! Again, if you don’t believe me then try travelling by PMPML bus on a
busy work day morning or evening time, right from bus stops to time table
everything is a mess & yet I congratulate to all those who travels by PMPML
as well its personnel (read as, staff) who are part of this system to keep it
working or else Pune roads would have been, God knows what!
And then
there was another news which made the headlines here in Pune as well in
Maharashtra also as it was about demolition of Noida Towers by muffled inward
blasting. These were illegal buildings in Noida, UP & has been ordered by
Hon Supreme Court to demolish but the legal fight went for nearly 15 years. Joke is, in this country getting an
order to demolish an illegal building takes 15 years (that also is early,
actually) but the order to demolish a legally built bridge or fly-over with
public money, takes just a minute! As usual there were Memes & Jokes
on social media about demolition of these towers & sadly right from our Hon
CM to even Hon High Court judges started giving example of demolition of these
buildings! Where are we heading guys, is it some Al-Qaeda or Don Corleone
giving threat by using such illegal building’s demolition as a set example,
come-on, how such buildings can ever come in the existence in the first place
that their demolition the govt portraying as victory or success, can someone
ask this question to the system, at least the builders must ask this who built
(or try to build) by following the law (read as, laws)? And who has stopped the govt to
demolish every illegal structure like the Noida Towers but before that, think
of demolishing the system which allows such illegal buildings to be built, is
what I will say!
Its high-time
to build a system which will stop giving birth to illegal buildings & stop
forcing people to use private vehicles for their daily uses or else Jane will
have to write her new book about “Death of the Cities in India” & we will
be definitely topping the list Punekars, mind it!
-
Sanjay
Deshpande
Sanjeevani
Dev.
Please view my sharing about real
estate in Pune at You Tube link below..
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4xX7eopH5o&t=5s
Please
do visit my blog links below to read about real estate & home buying!
https://visonoflife.blogspot.com/2021/09/choosing-right-home.html
http://jivnachadrushtikon.blogspot.com/2021/09/blog-post_21.html
Creating Togetherness; team Sanjeevani Way (Click link below)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/65629150@N06/albums/72157627904681345
For any of your complaints about city, log in at link below
www.punecorporation.org
Take your issues to
Hon PM at link below..
Think
Green, Think Life
www.sanjeevanideve.com / https://junglebelles.in/